Small Church & Forms 941/944

We are a very small church with two priests, both part time. We do no withholding of taxes for them but we do do a W-2 for them which is mainly a housing allowance.

We recently lost our treasurer and I’m helping as a volunteer do the year end stuff. Trying to do the W-2s online but when I try to submit online I have to declare kind of PAyer. I assume we are 941 or 944 payer but can find no record that we have ever filed a 941 which makes sense as we pay no withholding taxes.

What should I do? Is there a number I can call the IRS To find out if we have done those are if we need to do it or if I cannot file on line because of this situation. Thank you for your help hope this all makes sense.
LF